Someone help me with this riddle!!!

[3Razors]

Hey guys my girlfriend is driving me crazy with this riddle she gave me. I cant figure it out. Here goes.......

There are two centurions. One of them always tells the truth, the other one always tells a lie. Both of them are in a room with two doors each centurion guarding a door. One door leads to paradise, the other door leads to hell. You can only ask one question to one of the centurions. What question would you ask so you will find the door to paradise?!

[dreadhed]

Since a woman asked you I would have to say the answer would be "am I fat?" That is the best answer I can think of. I get asked does this make me look fat by my lady.

[Billy Golightly]

I dont think there is one. You have to ask a question to get an answer to know which one it it is, but by then you've already asked the question you were allowed to have. Atleast thats how I look at it.

[MTS]

Ask for 5 more questions :lol: :lol: or maby, Which door is the paridise door...lol

[Billy Golightly]

Its either that, or its just a guess. Because your taking a 50/50 chance on whatever you ask being true or false when answered since you dont know which one is the liar and which one tells the truth.

[3Razors]

My head really hurts from thinking about it tooo much!!!

[MTS]

Its either that, or its just a guess. Because your taking a 50/50 chance on whatever you ask being true or false when answered since you dont know which one is the liar and which one tells the truth.
Oh i didnt catch that part!!!

[dreadhed]

I have another answer. What color are my eyes? If one all ways lies then you will know right away.

[bigredhead]

Is this exactly how it was written ? word for word ?

[bigredhead]

I have another answer. What color are my eyes? If one all ways lies then you will know right away.

True. but then you've used up your question and canot find out wich door is heaven..:lol:

[Billy Golightly]

Right, but you still dont know which door is which :D

[3Razors]

I have another answer. What color are my eyes? If one all ways lies then you will know right away.

Thats pretty sneaky!!! I like that

Apperently there is an answer, she knows it, but likes to see me struggle.

[Billy Golightly]

Logically the one that tells the truth would be infront of the door to heaven and the one that lies infront of the door to hell. But the riddle doesnt say for sure...

[dreadhed]

Yes women like to make use struggle once in awhile. It's good for us to use our brain but not to offten.

[dreadhed]

Logically the one that tells the truth would be infront of the door to heaven and the one that lies infront of the door to hell. But the riddle doesnt say for sure...
You got me there. So here is my new answer. Knock the old people out & look behind the door for yourself. lol

[3Razors]

I think the main thing is to find out which one is the lyer then go from there...

Im pretty sure that i wrote the riddle word for word

[Tri-ZNate]

You ask "what would the other guy say that you would say?" then go with the opposite door.

[Tri-ZNate]

I'm pretty sure that it

[dreadhed]

Never mind

[Yamahauler]

You ask "what would the other guy say that you would say?" then go with the opposite door.
Thats right...well its something like that. I heard this one a long time ago

[Billy Golightly]

But you dont know which door either one of them is standing in front of like I mentioned above...

[Yamahauler]

Draw it out on paint, I dont want to put my pic up, it sucks.
But it definatly does work.

[Pistonhead]

I'm not sure what the answer is, but heaven or hell, I have friends in both places:lol:

[Tri-ZNate]

So? Either way you make it to paradise.

[xd 200x]

do you want the answer? you guys are way off by the way

[3Razors]

I appreciate everyone trying to help. If anyone has heard this riddle before and knows the answer please put my mind at ease.

Wheeliepop's line im still thinking about....

[Tri-ZNate]

the line I said is what we were told when we figured it out in school.

[xd 200x]

here is the answer
You ask one what the other one would say if you asked him which door is the door to hell and then open that door.

[3Razors]

Sheesh! Thank you. Even with the answer im still figuring it out in my head. lol

[xd 200x]

do you want me to explain it to you?

[Yamahauler]

here is the answer
You ask one what the other one would say if you asked him which door is the door to hell and then open that door.
thats what me and wheeliepop said, except we said ask him which is the door to paradise and then pick the opposite door.

[xd 200x]

let me explain Door 2 is hell dor 1 is heaven

You ask the one that lies what the other one would say of course the one that tells the truth would say that door 2 is the door to hell but being as you asked the one who lies he would say that they guy said door 1 is hell

now you ask the guy who tells the truth of couse the guy who lies would say that door 1 is hell and since he has to tell the truth he would say that the guy said 1

It dosent work in reverse unless you pick the opsite door. I hope that this makes sence It's late and im really tired and it's off the top of my head

[bigredhead]

You need to be allowed 2 questions to get the right door... one will not suffice. argh..... this is givin me a headache.

[xd 200x]

no you need one. we arlready figured it out read the post above yours for the explination

[bigredhead]

But you can only ask one question can't you ? if you ask one a question.. then you can't ask the other one a question as well.. that makes 2 questions.. not one.. arghhhhh.

[bigredhead]

Hey guys my girlfriend is driving me crazy with this riddle she gave me. I cant figure it out. Here goes.......

You can only ask one question to one of the centurions. What question would you ask so you will find the door to paradise?!


well.........

[xd 200x]

you ask 1 what the other would say that is you one question

[bigredhead]

But you don't know wich one is the liar and wich one tells the truth.. as well as wich door is what.... so to find out who is the liar and who is not.. you have to ask a question to qualify this first.. and that's your only question allowed... doh..

[xd 200x]

let me explain Door 2 is hell dor 1 is heaven
lets say
You ask the one that lies what the other one would say of course the one that tells the truth would say that door 2 is the door to hell but being as you asked the one who lies he would say that they guy said door 1 is hell

now if you ask the guy who tells the truth of couse the guy who lies would say that door 1 is hell and since he has to tell the truth he would say that the guy said 1

It dosent work in reverse unless you pick the opsite door. I hope that this makes sence It's late and im really tired and it's off the top of my head

read this and think about it. If you still dont understand post your email and I will send you a picuter of how it would work